Good Beer Guide Selection

Selecting Pubs for the Good Beer Guide

Every member of the branch is able to vote for their favourite pubs. The branch collates all the votes from all of our members. The pubs which receive most votes are included in the Good Beer Guide. Entry in the Guide is limited by a quota reflecting the page-space available.

PLEASE, all members use your vote! Download the PDF covering letter and PDF voting form for the 2022 Good Beer Guide using the links at the bottom of this page. The covering letter contains a full set of instructions. The voting form is also available as an Excel spreadsheet if you prefer to edit the form and return by email.

A member is usually eligible to vote for a pub if they have actually visited the pub and drank there in the previous 12 months (unless they have a personal interest in the operation of the pub). For 2022, this period has been extended to 24 months (i.e. since February 2019).

We use a weighted voting system, which allows you to indicate the strength of conviction regarding each pub. The reason why we want to differentiate between "blank" and "zero" votes is to have an idea of how many of our voting members visit each pub, even if they do not necessarily feel strongly enough about it to vote one way or another, and how many of our outlets are not being visited.

Blank I have not been in this pub within the last year
-2 Strongly against, "over my dead body" (not literally, please)
-1 Against inclusion in the Good Beer Guide, but not absolutely
0 I have been there, but I can't make up my mind
1 I am generally in favour of this pub being in the Good Beer Guide
2 This pub should definitely be in the Good Beer Guide

Selection Process

In an attempt to make things equitable, a geographical weighting is used which favours pubs outside Aberdeen city. This comes in the shape of a multiplicative factor:

1x Pubs in central Aberdeen, defined as the area formed by the river Dee, the river Don and the A90. In addition, there is an additional restriction of no more than 10 entries for this area.

2x Pubs in the rest of Aberdeen City, and the near commuter area - including the public transport corridors as far as and including Stonehaven, Banchory, Westhill, Inverurie, Oldmeldrum and Ellon, but not pubs inside this area with poor or non-existent public transport links.

3x Pubs that are anywhere else in the branch area. 

Selection Meeting

2021 Guide: The meeting to select pubs for the 2021 Guide was held at Ma Cameron's Snug on Sat 15th February 2020. This included the Pub of the Year (POTY) voting for City, Country & Northern Isles pubs as well as the Beer Of The Year / Brewery Of The Year (New) voting.

2022 Guide: The meeting to confirm pubs for the 2022 Guide will be a virtual meeting where the nominated pubs are based upon a compilation of votes received by mid-March 2022. The competitions for Pub, Brewery or Beer of the Year have been cancelled and are therefore not included in this years voting.